← Opportunities

Project Tachyon - Bonus Grant for Ironwood zk-SNARK Formal Verification

Funder
Zcash Coinholder Grants Program · Coinholder Retroactive Grants Program ✅ Proven payer
Type / status
other · open
Amount
261,058 USD
Deadline
unknown
Ecosystems
zcash
Categories
research
Tech stack
Apply
https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/52
Source
https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/project-tachyon-bonus-grant-for-ironwood-zk-snark-formal-verification/57021
Fit
35% · weak fit · The Tachyon Foundation's work on Ironwood zk-SNARK formal verification is adjacent to the Venture23 team's expertise in ZK and cryptography, though they operate in the Aleo ecosystem rather than Zcash.
Trust
88% · model self-report 85% · first seen 2026-09-30 · v1
Verified
2026-11-16 · page still up, no closing language

This is a bonus grant nomination for the Tachyon Foundation to recognize additional value for their completed formal verification work on the Ironwood zk-SNARK. The work was already submitted in application #50 and verified as complete. The nominator recommends coinholders approve an additional $261,058 to bring total recognition to $1,000,000 for the emergency cryptographic verification work performed in June-July 2026. Applications are submitted via GitHub issue #52 in the Zcash Coinholder Grants Program repository, requiring agreement to grant terms and KYC if over $50,000.

Eligibility: Open to Zcash coinholders who can nominate completed work for retroactive grants; funds go to Tachyon Foundation as the sole recipient.

Pipeline

Override status:

Funder track record · does Zcash Community actually pay grants?

✅ Proven payer · 31 grantees found · last payout 2026-10-30 · checked 2026-10-29 · 1 forum reports, 10 web pages read, 3 unverifiable claims dropped

Proven payer: at least 3 named grantees and one payout in the last 90 days. Every grantee below is quoted word for word from its source. When a source does not date a grant, the date is when that page or post was published.

GranteeAmountDateEvidence
Zcash WalletConnect Integration$8,0002026-10-30“Next · **2026-10-30** · [Zcash WalletConnect Integration](/zcg/grant?g=Zcash%20WalletConnect%20Integration), 5**$8,000**” source
QEDIT$5,755,4682026-10-26
page date
“[QEDIT](/zcg/recipient?r=QEDIT "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $5,755,468 $5,982,968 136,672.85536 10” source
Zcash Open Development Lab (ZODL)$1,950,0002026-10-26
page date
“[Zcash Open Development Lab (ZODL)](/zcg/recipient?r=Zcash%20Open%20Development%20Lab%20\(ZODL\) "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,950,000 $1,950,000 1,701.4371 1” source
Valargroup$1,802,0002026-10-26
page date
“[Valargroup](/zcg/recipient?r=Valargroup "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,802,000 $1,802,000 1,572.3024 2” source
Taylor Hornby$1,658,5002026-10-26
page date
“[Taylor Hornby](/zcg/recipient?r=Taylor%20Hornby "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,658,500 $1,658,500 5,868.5248 3” source
Hanh$1,627,030.742026-10-26
page date
“[Hanh](/zcg/recipient?r=Hanh "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,627,030.74 $1,705,030.74 34,200.118643 13” source
Equilibrium$1,452,2002026-10-26
page date
“[Equilibrium](/zcg/recipient?r=Equilibrium "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,452,200 $1,452,200 30,666.1802069 6” source
Tor$1,389,8562026-10-26
page date
“[Tor](/zcg/recipient?r=Tor "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,389,856 $1,389,856 18,952.08 3” source
Zingo Labs$1,234,957.442026-10-26
page date
“[Zingo Labs](/zcg/recipient?r=Zingo%20Labs "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,234,957.44 $1,292,157.44 27,099.731 9” source
Nighthawk$1,142,9862026-10-26
page date
“[Nighthawk](/zcg/recipient?r=Nighthawk "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,142,986 $1,142,986 22,104.2785862 5” source
Zcash Media$1,056,4702026-10-26
page date
“[Zcash Media](/zcg/recipient?r=Zcash%20Media "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,056,470 $1,056,470 25,427.0095483 4” source
Least Authority$1,028,882.382026-10-26
page date
“[Least Authority](/zcg/recipient?r=Least%20Authority "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,028,882.38 $1,028,882.38 11,660.3824 ·” source
Tachyon Foundation$1,000,0002026-10-26
page date
“[Tachyon Foundation](/zcg/recipient?r=Tachyon%20Foundation "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $1,000,000 $1,000,000 872.5318 2” source
ZecHub$728,312.432026-10-26
page date
“[ZecHub](/zcg/recipient?r=ZecHub "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $728,312.43 $822,392.43 10,407.3793 5” source
sangsoo-osec$612,5002026-10-26
page date
“[sangsoo-osec](/zcg/recipient?r=sangsoo-osec "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $612,500 $612,500 529.1848 1” source
Zec.rocks$584,9922026-10-26
page date
“[Zec.rocks](/zcg/recipient?r=Zec.rocks "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $584,992 $584,992 510.4241 1” source
Zcash Brazil$581,452.432026-10-26
page date
“[Zcash Brazil](/zcg/recipient?r=Zcash%20Brazil "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $581,452.43 $655,955.43 8,087.4274 7” source
ZecWallet$475,9002026-10-26
page date
“[ZecWallet](/zcg/recipient?r=ZecWallet "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $475,900 $475,900 4,038.3187322 3” source
Free2Z$468,0372026-10-26
page date
“[Free2Z](/zcg/recipient?r=Free2Z "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $468,037 $468,037 14,224.5220588 3” source
Pacu$419,984.492026-10-26
page date
“[Pacu](/zcg/recipient?r=Pacu "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $419,984.49 $419,984.49 9,377.27 4” source
Alex Sol$400,0002026-10-26
page date
“[Alex Sol](/zcg/recipient?r=Alex%20Sol "See this recipient's milestones and payments") $400,000 $400,000 349.0127 1” source
developers and security researchers who helped discover and fix the Orchard vulnerabilityseveral million dollars2026-10-01“Wilcox noted that several million dollars of the approved funding are specifically set aside for developers and security researchers who helped discover and fix the Orchard vulnerability.” source
auditing the affected code—2026-10-01“The remaining allocations cover auditing the affected code and delivering the Ironwood upgrade, which appears to be tied to the same remediation effort.” source
delivering the Ironwood upgrade—2026-10-01“The remaining allocations cover auditing the affected code and delivering the Ironwood upgrade, which appears to be tied to the same remediation effort.” source
Taylor Hornby$1.5 million2026-10-01“Zcash holders approved $1.5 million for Taylor Hornby after his discovery of Orchard's critical vulnerability.” source
ZODL$1.95 million2026-10-01“Coinholders approved $1.95 million for ZODL's Q1 and Q2 core protocol development” source
ValarGroup$1.203 million2026-10-01“$1.203 million for ValarGroup's Ironwood work” source
Formal verification of the Ironwood zk-SNARK circuit$738,9422026-10-01“$738,942 went toward formal verification of the Ironwood zk-SNARK circuit” source
External audit costs$599,0002026-10-01“$599,000 covered external audit costs” source
Five critical Zebra consensus-divergence vulnerabilities$425,0002026-10-01“$425,000 covering five critical Zebra consensus-divergence vulnerabilities” source
Temporary detectable unlimited-mint-and-sell exploit$400,0002026-10-01“$400,000 award connected with a temporary detectable unlimited-mint-and-sell exploit” source
Zebra vulnerability bounty$150,0002026-10-01“$150,000 Zebra vulnerability bounty” source
vancube—2026-09-23
post date
“ZecLedger grant update” forum

Trust breakdown (3/3 checkable facts verified)

SignalWeightResultNote
amount0.25100%figure appears in source
apply link0.075100%link in source
funder0.075100%named in source
source quality0.1560%forum post
model confidence0.185%model self-report

Fit breakdown (against the ORG_* profile)

SignalWeightResultNote
model fit0.570%model rated 70%
ecosystem overlap0.250%zcash vs aleo
category overlap0.150%research vs zk, privacy, infra, dev_tooling, security, interoperability
tech overlap0.10%none vs rust, leo, zk

Sources (1)

RoleDocumentFromFetched
primaryProject Tachyon - Bonus Grant for Ironwood zk-SNARK Formal VerificationZcash community forum2026-09-30

History (1)

vChangedFields
12026-09-30created

Extracted text

I’ve submitted a **bonus grant** nomination for the formal verification work done by the [Tachyon Foundation](https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/retroactive-grant-application-ironwood-zk-snark-formal-verification-project-tachyon/57007). It was inspired by [Zooko’s post](https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/retroactive-grant-application-give-bigger-grants-to-taylor-and-tachyon/57012) suggesting we should be able to nominate people for retroactive grants instead of waiting for them to apply, and that he believes the team should receive more. [@frankbraun](/u/frankbraun) also reached out to me separately to advocate for a bonus grant for the Tachyon team, having come to the same conclusion on his own. I agree.

Project Tachyon’s application prices their emergency work at the bottom of the market band and claims nothing for the two-month stall to their own roadmap. I’m recommending coinholders approve an additional **$261,058**, bringing their total for the Ironwood formal verification to $1,000,000.

I’m submitting this in my personal capacity, Tachyon had no role in it, and none of the funds go to me or Shielded Labs.

[github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/52)

#### [Project Tachyon - Bonus Grant for Ironwood zk-SNARK Formal Verification](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/52)

opened 12:13PM - 14 Aug 26 UTC

 [![](https://global.discourse-cdn.com/zcash/original/3X/0/1/012b6818fb52e255a1cd26456dfb7c6bd563bb10.jpeg) aquietinvestor](https://github.com/aquietinvestor)

Ready For Vote - All Steps Completed

\### Terms and Conditions - \[x\] I agree to the \[Grant Agreement\](https://9ba4718…c-5c73-47c3-a024-4fc4e5278803.usrfiles.com/ugd/9ba471\_6ff6db4095fd4c4ba21babec361e927e.pdf) terms if funded - \[x\] I agree to \[Provide KYC information\](https://9ba4718c-5c73-47c3-a024-4fc4e5278803.usrfiles.com/ugd/9ba471\_7d9e73d16b584a61bae92282b208efc4.pdf) if funded above $50,000 USD - \[x\] I agree to disclose conflicts of interest - \[x\] I understand that this grant program is only eligible for completed work, as it is a retroactive grant program. Applications for planned or partially completed work will not be considered. All completed work will be verified and accepted by its intended users or their representatives, who will confirm that the outputs meet the required quality, functionality, and usability before the work is listed as an option for Coinholder voting. - \[x\] I agree that for any new open-source software, I will create a CONTRIBUTING.md file that reflects the high standards of Zcash development, using the \[\`librustzcash\` style guides\](https://github.com/zcash/librustzcash/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#styleguides) as a primary reference. - \[x\] I understand when contributing to existing Zcash code, I am required to adhere to the project specific contribution guidelines, paying close attention to any \[merge\](https://github.com/zcash/librustzcash/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#merge-workflow), \[branch\](https://github.com/zcash/librustzcash/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#branch-history), \[pull request\](https://github.com/zcash/librustzcash/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#pull-request-review), and \[commit\](https://github.com/zcash/librustzcash/blob/main/CONTRIBUTING.md#commit-messages) guidelines as exemplified in the librustzcash repository. - \[x\] I understand all grants are valued in USD but will be disbursed in Shielded ZEC. I acknowledge and accept that disbursement amounts may fluctuate based on the ZEC/USD exchange rate at the time of payment. ### Application Owners (@octocat, @octocat1) @aquietinvestor ### Organization or Individual Name Jason McGee. I am recommending coinholders approve a bonus grant to Tachyon Foundation, the sole recipient, bringing their total for the Ironwood formal verification to $1,000,000. I am submitting this in my personal capacity as a coinholder; no funds go to me or to Shielded Labs, where I serve as Executive Director. ### Additional Team Members \`\`\`team-members.yaml None. Tachyon Foundation did not request this nomination and had no role in preparing it. The team that performed the work is identified in the following application: https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50 \`\`\` ### How did you learn about the Lockbox: Coinholder Retroactive Grants Program? I helped create the Coinholder Retroactive Grants Program and helped administer its first rounds, and Shielded Labs is one of the keyholder organizations. This nomination was prompted by reading application #50 and concluding that Tachyon asked for too little. ### Requested Grant Amount (USD) $261,058 ### Category Research & Development ### Project Summary This is a bonus grant nomination, not a standard application. Tachyon Foundation applied for $738,942 in \[application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50) for leading the formal verification of the Ironwood zk-SNARK. That application deliberately excludes real costs they absorbed and prices their emergency work at the bottom of the market band. I believe coinholders should recognize the full value of what they did. This application adds $261,058, bringing the total recognition for the Ironwood formal verification to an even $1,000,000. ### Project Description This application was inspired by \[Zooko's forum post\](https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/retroactive-grant-application-give-bigger-grants-to-taylor-and-tachyon/57012) suggesting we should be able to nominate people for retroactive grants rather than waiting for them to apply, and that Tachyon and Taylor both asked for too little. I agree, and this application acts on it. Frank Braun also reached out to me separately to advocate for a bonus grant for both applicants, having come to the same conclusion on his own The work itself is described in \[application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50) and I won't restate it here. In short: after the Orchard counterfeiting vulnerability was disclosed in June 2026, Tachyon dropped everything, implemented the Ironwood circuit changes, funded two independent verification firms out of their own audit budget, and delivered a machine-checked Lean formalization of the Ironwood zk-SNARK verifier on the day of mainnet activation. Formal verification of a deployed cryptographic protocol is normally measured in years. They did it in under two months, against a fixed deadline, because the ecosystem needed it. The reason for this application is what #50 leaves out. By their own accounting, Tachyon claims nothing for the two-month stall of their own roadmap, nothing for the burden on team members who carried Project Tachyon with reduced support during the pivot, no mobilization fee, and billing at the bottom of the emergency-response band. Those are real costs. They chose not to price them, which speaks well of them, but the community does not have to accept that discount. There is also a strategic reason. The people who can do this work are rare. Zcash was lucky that a team with the right expertise, including a principal author of halo2, existed and was willing to act immediately with no guarantee of payment. Retroactive grants are the mechanism we have for making sure that kind of decisive action is rewarded, so that the people capable of it stay in this ecosystem and act just as decisively next time. Paying exactly cost for emergency work teaches the wrong lesson. The amount is chosen simply: $738,942 plus $261,058 equals $1,000,000. I think a million dollars is a fair round number for work that resolved an existential question about the ZEC supply. ### Technical Approach (how you did it) Not applicable. This application adds no new work. The technical approach is documented in \[application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50) and in Tachyon's publications. ### Time Period of Work Completion June 1, 2026 - July 28, 2026 (the same period as application #50) ### Total Budget (USD) $261,058 ### Budget Breakdown Other: $261,058. Justification: a bonus to Tachyon Foundation in recognition of the unclaimed indirect costs and below-market pricing in \[application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50), including the roughly two-month delay to their own roadmap, the burden on their team during the pivot, and emergency billing at the bottom of the market band with no mobilization fee. This application does not itemize those costs; #50 documents that they were incurred and not claimed. The figure is set so that total recognition for the work equals $1,000,000. ### Previous Funding No ### Previous Funding Details Not applicable ### Other Funding Sources No ### Other Funding Sources Details No funding source covers this bonus. Tachyon Foundation's own funding history is disclosed in \[application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50). ### Success Metrics The success metrics for the underlying work are in\[ application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50): the machine-checked proof was published, Ironwood activated on schedule, and confidence in the ZEC supply was restored. The success metric for this application is different: that coinholders affirm, on the record, that emergency work of this caliber is worth more than its billed cost, and that the people who protect Zcash are rewarded well. ### Proof of completion All proof of completion is in \[application #50\](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/50): the public Lean formalization at github.com/zcash/ironwood, the merged circuit implementation in zcash/orchard#504, the published announcements, and the Ironwood mainnet activation on July 28, 2026. ### Conflict of Interest Disclosure 1. I am the Executive Director of Shielded Labs, one of the keyholder organizations of this grants program. I also helped create the program and helped administer its first rounds. I am submitting this nomination in my personal capacity, and no funds go to me or to Shielded Labs. 2. I provided a supporting statement for application #50, quoted in that application, in my capacity at Shielded Labs. 3. Shielded Labs worked alongside Tachyon Foundation, Valar Group, and ZODL on the Ironwood upgrade, and Ironwood originated as a Shielded Labs proposal. I have direct professional knowledge of the work described here. 4. Tachyon Foundation did not request, review, or contribute to this application. They may decline the funds if they wish. 5. I am a ZEC coinholder and participate in coinholder polls. ### Community Forum Posting - \[x\] I understand it is my responsibility to post a link to this issue on the \[Zcash Community Forums\](https://forum.zcashcommunity.com/t/about-the-retroactive-grants-category/52106) after this application has been submitted so the community can give input. I understand this is required in order for the community to discuss and vote on this grant application. Note: If you are unable to post on the forum (for example, due to new user restrictions), please leave a comment below, and we will adjust your posting permissions.